Should Corporal Punishment Be Used in K-12 Schools

Because the Supreme Court of Canada decided in 2004 that schoolteachers can no longer use S. 43 as a defence to corporal punishment of students, such punishment is now illegal throughout Canada. All education acts should therefore be amended to make them consistent with the Court’s decision and to make this change known as widely as possible. The education acts of Manitoba and Alberta are the only two that have not yet made this clear. We have written ministers of education in these provinces requesting such an amendment but neither act has been changed.

Should Corporal Punishment be used in Public Schools…

Corporal Punishment In School Should Be Banned Free …

Corporal Punishment In School Should Be Banned

Racial disparities. Opponents often claim that corporal punishment is racially discriminatory because statistics show that black students are more likely to be paddled than white ones, to the population as a whole. In fact, though, the same applies to suspensions and other kinds of punishment, so while there may be a "racial problem" in school discipline overall, it is not specifically a "corporal punishment problem". discusses this point, with particular reference to Mississippi, where about 50% of all public school students are black, but black students account for 64% of those officially spanked. The article notes that many black people strongly support CP, and some view it as a valued part of their cultural heritage.

Should corporal punishment be used in schools

Not only are such messages thought to be wrong in themselves, but it is claimed that they are then acted upon by the child who is hit.18 In the short term, those who are physically punished are alleged to commit violence against other children, against teachers and against school property.19 As far as long term effects are concerned, it is alleged that significant numbers of people who commit crimes were physically punished as children. It is these arguments that lie behind the adage "violence breeds violence." Three defenses of (limited) corporal punishment can be advanced against this objection.

Vaguely formulated school rules in Qingdao incite fears that they could be used to justify corporal punishment.
Home > Opinions > News > Why should corporal punishment be banned in schools

Corporal punishment is the act of using ..

Students: Tell us what you think about corporal punishment in school. Is it permitted, and used, in your state and your school? Do you support or oppose it, and why? What do you think about the fact that some students and alumni — not just school officials — think corporal punishment should be used in school?

Does corporal punishment still exist in the US? Believe it or not, it does, and it is still used in public schools in 22 states. Learn more.

Corporal punishment means physical torture

Those who advance the objection that corporal punishment fosters masochism are rarely clear about the nature of the masochistic inclinations that they say are produced. Yet, it is crucial to be clear about this. Studies show that most people have been sexually aroused, either in fantasy or in practice, by at least some mild masochistic activity, such as restraint or play fights.16 Thus, some masochistic tendencies seem to be statistically normal. That does not preclude their being undesirable, but it is hard to see how, in an era of increased tolerance of diversity in sexual orientation and practice, we can consistently label mild masochism as perverse. If such inclinations increase opportunities for sexual pleasure without concomitant harms, then there is at least a prima facie case for the view that such inclinations are not to be regretted. And if one objects to those masochistic inclinations that seek gratification in more serious pain, injury, and bondage, there is no evidence of which I am aware that mild and infrequent corporal punishment fosters such inclinations. The available evidence linking corporal punishment and masochism makes the connection only with milder forms of masochistic fantasy and practice.

Should Corporal Punishment be used in Public Schools? essays One could define corporal punishment as harming/inflicting pain in any way, shape, or form to the body.

Yes, schools should be allowed to use corporal punishment.

There are some significant differences between the home and school settings. Parents are more likely to have their children's interests close to heart and to love and care for them. Parents are also more likely to know their children better than teachers know their pupils. Teachers, after all, have relatively little contact with their pupils and the little they do have is usually in large classes. While some people are opposed to corporal punishment anywhere, even by parents in the home, others oppose only its practice outside the home. They might suggest that the differences between the home and the school are morally relevant and show why corporal punishment would be acceptable in the home but not in the school.