Solution to the problem of evil? | Yahoo Answers
Solution to the problem of evil
If the ontological argument were sound, it would provide a ratherdecisive refutation of the argument from evil. For in showing notmerely that there is an omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfectbeing, but also that it is necessary that such a being exists, it wouldentail that the proposition that God does not exist must haveprobability zero on any body of evidence whatever.
The Evil of Slavery Free Short Essay Example
Short of embracing compete inductive skepticism, then, it would seemthat an appeal to human cognitive limitations cannot provide ananswer to evidential versions of the argument from evil.
September 2004 Remember the essays you had to write in high school
The fourth and final approach, which has been set out by MichaelTooley, involves the idea of bringing a substantive theory ofinductive logic, or logical probability, to bear upon the argumentfrom evil, and then to argue that when this is done, one can derive aformula giving the probability that God does not exist relative toinformation about the number of apparent evils to be found in theworld.
John Locke (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
The problem, then, is that Plantinga not only started out by focusingon very abstract versions of the argument from evil, but alsomaintained this focus throughout. The explanation of this may lie inthe fact that Plantinga seems to have believed that if it can be shownthat the existence of God is neither incompatible with, nor renderedimprobable by, either (1) the mere existence of evil, or (2) theexistence of a specified amount of evil, then no philosophical problemremains. People may find, of course, that they are still troubled bythe existence of specific evils, but this, Plantinga seems to bebelieve, is a religious problem, and what is called for, he suggests,is not philosophical argument, but “pastoralcare” (1974a,63–4).